| 4 | WK Lees | Wellington v Otago | 1978/79 | f32351 |
| 4 | CD Fletcher | Otago v Canterbury | 2019/20 | f60089 |
| 3 | LW Downes | Otago v Central Districts | 1975/76 | f31007 |
| 3 | ML Ryan | Otago v Canterbury | 1977/78 | f31846 |
| 3 | WK Lees | Wellington v Otago | 1978/79 | f32351 |
| 3 | BD Milburn | Canterbury v Otago | 1982/83 | f34488 |
| 3 | RG Hart | Otago v Northern Districts | 1994/95 | f41643 |
| 3 | MG Croy | Central Districts v Otago | 1996/97 | f42967 |
| 3 | E Austin | Otago v Central Districts | 1996/97 | f42967 |
| 3 | BBJ Griggs | Otago v Central Districts | 2009/10 | f52300 |
| 3 | DC de Boorder | Wellington v Otago | 2013/14 | f55218 |
| 3 | L Ronchi | Otago v Wellington | 2013/14 | f55218 |
| 3 | M Renwick | Canterbury v Otago | 2019/20 | f60089 |