| 4 | BD Milburn | Wellington v Otago | 1982/83 | a3526 |
| 4 | WK Lees | Wellington v Otago | 1986/87 | a5104 |
| 4 | SA Robinson | Northern Districts v Otago | 1992/93 | a7865 |
| 4 | GR Baker | Northern Districts v Otago | 1993/94 | a8435 |
| 3 | G Fowler | Otago v England XI | 1983/84 | a3906 |
| 3 | EB McSweeney | Otago v Wellington | 1988/89 | a5915 |
| 3 | IDS Smith | Otago v Auckland | 1991/92 | a7351 |
| 3 | EB McSweeney | Otago v Wellington | 1992/93 | a7871 |
| 3 | RG Hart | Otago v Northern Districts | 1994/95 | a9011 |
| 3 | MG Croy | Wellington v Otago | 1994/95 | a9034 |
| 3 | CJ Nevin | Otago v Wellington | 1995/96 | a9620 |
| 3 | CJ Nevin | Otago v Wellington | 1996/97 | a10282 |
| 3 | SA Robinson | Canterbury v Otago | 1996/97 | a10284 |
| 3 | MG Croy | Wellington v Otago | 1997/98 | a10906 |
| 3 | MS Sinclair | Otago v Central Districts | 1997/98 | a10909 |
| 3 | MG Croy | Central Districts v Otago | 1997/98 | a10909 |
| 3 | JM Mills | Otago v Auckland | 1998/99 | a11617 |
| 3 | L Vincent | Otago v Auckland | 1999/00 | a12337 |
| 3 | PD McGlashan | Auckland v Otago | 2002/03 | a14815 |
| 3 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Otago | 2003/04 | a15615 |
| 3 | CFK van Wyk | Otago v Canterbury | 2007/08 | a18637 |
| 3 | TL Seifert | Otago v Northern Districts | 2014/15 | a23845 |
| 3 | CD Fletcher | Otago v Canterbury | 2015/16 | a24486 |