| 6 | CD Cumming | 2001/02 |
| 5 | RCD Silver | 1937/38 |
| 5 | CB Gaffaney | 1996/97 |
| 5 | CB Gaffaney | 2001/02 |
| 5 | MG Croy | 2001/02 |
| 5 | JS Hunter | 2015/16 |
| 4 | IW Payne | 1951/52 |
| 4 | AM Moir | 1951/52 |
| 4 | KO Campbell | 1969/70 |
| 4 | CM Kirk | 1977/78 |
| 4 | TD Sutherland | 1979/80 |
| 4 | WK Lees | 1981/82 |
| 4 | IS Billcliff | 1992/93 |
| 4 | RJ Kennedy | 1996/97 |
| 4 | DG Sewell | 2001/02 |
| 4 | JW Sheed | 2004/05 |
| 4 | RJ Nicol | 2017/18 |
| 4 | MD Rae | 2017/18 |
| 4 | MD Rae | 2020/21 |
| 4 | D Foxcroft | 2023/24 |
| 4 | JA Duffy | 2023/24 |