Teams Nicola Payne played for

Women's ODINetherlands Women (1988/89-1998)
 New Zealand Women (1999/00-2002/03)
Women's First-ClassQueensland Women (1991/92)
Women's List AQueensland Women (1991/92)
 Canterbury Women (1995/96-2002/03)
 Netherlands Women (1988/89-1998)
 South Island Women (1998/99-1999/00)
 Central Districts and Wellington Women (1998/99)
 New Zealand Women (1999/00-2002/03)
Women's World CupNetherlands Women (1988/89-1997/98)
 New Zealand Women (2000/01)
Women's MiscellaneousNetherlands Women (1992-1993)
 New Zealand Women (2001/02-2002/03)