Teams Colin McVicar played for

Main FCCentral Districts (1950/51-1951/52)
Hawke CupManawatu (1934/35-1955/56)
Plunket ShieldCentral Districts (1950/51-1951/52)
MiscellaneousManawatu (1933/34-1955/56)
 Wellington Minor Associations (1937/38-1946/47)
 Wellington Country (1947/48-1949/50)
 Wellington Minor Associations West (1948/49)
 Manawatu Wanderers (1949/50)