| Main FC | Cambridge University (1867-1868) |
| Yorkshire (1867-1874) | |
| Canterbury (1871/72) | |
| Miscellaneous | Rossall School (1865) |
| Gentlemen of Yorkshire (1865-1880) | |
| Holbeck (1866) | |
| Cambridge University Freshmen (1867) | |
| Cambridge University (1867) | |
| Quidnuncs (1868-1880) | |
| Rotherham (1870) |