Teams Arthur Motley played for

Main FCYorkshire (1879)
 Wellington (1886/87-1888/89)
MiscellaneousHunslet (1878)
 Leeds Clarence (1878-1879)
 Leeds (1878)
 United North of England Eleven (1878)
 Wakefield (1879)
 Gentlemen of Yorkshire (1879)
 Wellington (1886/87-1887/88)