Teams Penny Kinsella played for

Women's TestNew Zealand Women (1989/90-1994/95)
Women's ODINew Zealand Women (1987/88-1994/95)
Women's First-ClassCentral Districts Women (1983/84-1986/87)
 Wellington Women (1989/90-1995/96)
Women's List ACentral Districts Women (1981/82-1987/88)
 Wellington Women (1988/89-1996/97)
Women's First-ClassNew Zealand Women (1989/90-1994/95)
 New Zealand President's XI Women (1991/92)
Women's List ANew Zealand Women (1987/88-1994/95)
 North Island Women (1993/94-1994/95)
Women's World CupNew Zealand Women (1993)
Women's MiscellaneousCentral Districts Women (1981/82)
 Manawatu Women (1981/82)
 New Zealand Women (1993)