| Main FC | Victoria (1909/10-1911/12) |
| | Wellington (1922/23-1926/27) |
| Other FC | Australian XI (1910/11) |
| | The Rest (1910/11) |
| | New Zealand (1923/24) |
| Halifax Cup | New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1915) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1916-1917) |
| | Manor Field (1919) |
| Victoria Premier Cricket | Essendon (1909/10-1911/12) |
| Sheffield Shield | Victoria (1909/10-1911/12) |
| Plunket Shield | Wellington (1922/23-1926/27) |
| Miscellaneous | San Francisco County (1904) |
| | Columbia Oval (1904-1915) |
| | Metropolitan District Cricket League (1904) |
| | ONT Athletic Club of Newark (1904) |
| | All New York (1904-1928) |
| | Hamilton (1905) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1906) |
| | Prospect Park Zingari (1907) |
| | Brooklyn (1907) |
| | Brooklyn Zingari (1907) |
| | Victoria (1909/10) |
| | South (1912/13-1913/14) |
| | Richmond County (1914-1917) |
| | New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1914-1916) |
| | New York Veterans (1914-1925) |
| | Manhattan (1916) |
| | HHL Kortlang's XI (1916) |
| | New York Halifax Cup XI (1917) |
| | 6th Canadian Field Engineers (1918) |
| | Vancouver (1918) |
| | Engineers (1918) |
| | Vancouver Military (1918) |
| | Manor Field (1919-1925) |
| | Marine Cricket Club (1919) |
| | New York City (1919) |
| | Norris' XI (1925) |
| | Wellington Town (1926/27) |
| | Wellington (1926/27) |
| | Fordham (1928) |
| | Montreal (1929) |
| | Montreal and District (1929) |
| | Montreal Amateur Athletic Association (1929) |
| | Quebec (1929) |