| Main FC | Europeans (1903/04) |
| Other FC | North Island (1893/94) |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1908/09) | |
| Halifax Cup | Philadelphia Cricket Club (1907-1911) |
| Miscellaneous | King William's Town (1895/96) |
| Philadelphia (1908-1910) | |
| Philadelphia Cricket Club (1908-1910) | |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1908/09) | |
| United States of America (1909-1911) | |
| All Philadelphia (1910-1911) | |
| Philadelphia Veterans (1910-1911) |