| Test | New Zealand (1958) |
| Main FC | Canterbury (1955/56-1958/59) |
| | Wellington (1959/60) |
| | Otago (1960/61-1961/62) |
| Other FC | New Zealand XI (1957/58) |
| | New Zealanders (1958) |
| | New Zealand (1958) |
| | South Island (1958/59) |
| Plunket Shield | Canterbury (1955/56-1958/59) |
| | Wellington (1959/60) |
| | Otago (1960/61-1961/62) |
| Miscellaneous | Canterbury Under-20s (1952/53-1955/56) |
| | Canterbury (1955/56-1956/57) |
| | IB Cromb's Canterbury Colts (1955/56) |
| | Canterbury XI (1956/57-1958/59) |
| | WM Wallace's XI (1957/58) |
| | New Zealand Universities (1957/58) |
| | Maori Club (1958) |
| | LC Stevens' XI (1958) |
| | New Zealanders (1958) |
| | Dunedin Metropolitan (1960/61-1961/62) |