| Test | New Zealand (1955/56-1971/72) |
| Main FC | Otago (1956/57-1971/72) |
| Other FC | New Zealanders (1955/56-1971/72) |
| | New Zealand (1955/56-1971/72) |
| | The Rest (1957/58) |
| | New Zealand XI (1957/58-1967/68) |
| | New Zealand Governor-General's XI (1960/61) |
| | Otago Invitation XI (1962/63) |
| Hawke Cup | Southland (1954/55-1974/75) |
| Plunket Shield | Otago (1956/57-1971/72) |
| Miscellaneous | South Island Colts (1948/49) |
| | Southland Under-20s (1949/50) |
| | Otago Under-20s (1949/50) |
| | Southland (1949/50-1972/73) |
| | New Zealand Universities (1951/52) |
| | Dunedin Metropolitan (1952/53) |
| | South Island Minor Associations (1952/53-1960/61) |
| | WM Wallace's XI (1952/53) |
| | Otago Country Associations and Southland (1954/55-1964/65) |
| | Central Otago and Southland (1956/57) |
| | New Zealanders (1958-1971/72) |
| | Maori Club (1958) |
| | New Zealand XI (1959/60) |
| | JR Reid's XI (1963/64) |
| | Otago Possibles (1966/67) |
| | Otago (1966/67) |
| | WM Anderson's XI (1967/68) |
| | Otago XI (1969/70-1971/72) |
| | GD Alabaster's XI (1971/72) |