| 6 | D Hunter | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1891 | f3622 |
| 5 | E Stephenson | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1864 | f1265 |
| 5 | G Pinder | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1872 | f1705 |
| 5 | JG Binks | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1961 | f23919 |
| 5 | G Clayton | Yorkshire v Lancashire | 1961 | f23919 |
| 5 | JG Binks | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1965 | f25935 |
| 5 | JG Binks | Essex v Yorkshire | 1969 | f27781 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 1972 | f29217 |