| 6 | J Tunnicliffe | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1893 | f3883 |
| 6 | J Tunnicliffe | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 1895 | f4271 |
| 6 | A Waddington | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1924 | f11030 |
| 6 | PJ Sharpe | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1959 | f22785 |
| 6 | PJ Sharpe | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1965 | f25773 |
| 6 | PJ Sharpe | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1967 | f26919 |
| 5 | EM Grace | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | 1876 | f1982 |
| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Sussex v Yorkshire | 1900 | f5397 |
| 5 | LC Braund | Australia v England | 1902 | f5889 |
| 5 | A Mitchell | Kent v Yorkshire | 1936 | f15340 |
| 5 | JD Bond | Yorkshire v Lancashire | 1957 | f21922 |
| 5 | FS Trueman | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1967 | f26805 |
| 5 | B Leadbeater | Worcestershire v Yorkshire | 1969 | f27846 |
| 5 | PJ Sharpe | Hampshire v Yorkshire | 1970 | f28240 |