| 15-57 | J Briggs | Lord Londesborough's XI v Australians | 1890 | f3566 |
| 14-185 | FR Spofforth | Australians v I Zingari | 1884 | f2831 |
| 13-40 | J Briggs | Lord Londesborough's XI v Australians | 1888 | f3333 |
| 13-45 | R Henderson | I Zingari v Yorkshire | 1877 | f2083 |
| 13-57 | CTB Turner | Australians v Lord Londesborough's XI | 1890 | f3566 |
| 13-63 | JM Preston | Yorkshire v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1888 | f3332 |
| 13-82 | GA Lohmann | South v North | 1891 | f3677 |
| 13-83 | T Emmett | Yorkshire v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1882 | f2573 |
| 13-96 | WE Bowes | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 1936 | f15532 |
| 13-183 | AE Trott | CI Thornton's XI v Yorkshire | 1899 | f5257 |
| 13-183 | WE Bowes | Yorkshire v Essex | 1932 | f14026 |
| 12-45 | S Haigh | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 1899 | f5137 |
| 12-53 | EP Robinson | Yorkshire v Hampshire | 1946 | f17299 |
| 12-74 | CT Studd | I Zingari v Yorkshire | 1881 | f2451 |
| 12-96 | R Peel | CI Thornton's XI v Australians | 1896 | f4579 |
| 12-97 | SMJ Woods | Gentlemen of England v I Zingari | 1890 | f3559 |
| 12-110 | T Emmett | Yorkshire v Middlesex | 1874 | f1855 |
| 12-111 | LC Braund | Marylebone Cricket Club v Yorkshire | 1902 | f5990 |
| 12-121 | GAE Paine | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1934 | f14704 |
| 12-122 | CTB Turner | Australians v Lord Londesborough's XI | 1888 | f3333 |
| 12-124 | R Appleyard | Yorkshire v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1954 | f20669 |
| 12-138 | P Willey | TN Pearce's XI v New Zealanders | 1978 | f32239 |