| 6 | JT Murray | India v England | 1967 | t619 |
| 6 | MJ Prior | South Africa v England | 2012 | t2053 |
| 5 | GRA Langley | England v Australia | 1956 | t426 |
| 5 | ATW Grout | England v Australia | 1961 | t508 |
| 5 | AJ Stewart | South Africa v England | 1998 | t1419 |
| 5 | MV Boucher | England v South Africa | 1998 | t1419 |
| 5 | AJ Stewart | Australia v England | 2001 | t1552 |
| 5 | KC Sangakkara | England v Sri Lanka | 2002 | t1603 |
| 5 | GO Jones | Sri Lanka v England | 2006 | t1802 |
| 5 | GO Jones | Pakistan v England | 2006 | t1809 |
| 5 | BJ Haddin | England v Australia | 2013 | t2091 |