| 7 | AFJ Ford | Gloucestershire v Middlesex | 1882 | f2489 |
| 6 | WG Grace | Yorkshire v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1873 | f1739 |
| 6 | AJ Webbe | Players v Gentlemen | 1877 | f2046 |
| 6 | GF Vernon | Nottinghamshire v Middlesex | 1888 | f3256 |
| 6 | W Chatterton | Marylebone Cricket Club v Derbyshire | 1895 | f4213 |
| 6 | RE Foster | Marylebone Cricket Club v Oxford University | 1898 | f4926 |
| 6 | GB Legge | Cambridge University v Oxford University | 1926 | f11642 |
| 6 | WJ Edrich | Surrey v Middlesex | 1949 | f18493 |
| 6 | CA Milton | Middlesex v Gloucestershire | 1953 | f20210 |
| 6 | MC Cowdrey | West Indies v England | 1963 | f24808 |
| 6 | GS Sobers | England v West Indies | 1973 | f29779 |
| 6 | AJ Lamb | New Zealand v England | 1983 | f34751 |
| 6 | GA Gooch | Middlesex v Essex | 1985 | f35956 |