| 4 | MA Lynch | Yorkshire v Surrey | 1984 | a4181 |
| 4 | AW Smith | Yorkshire v Surrey | 1993 | a8229 |
| 4 | GP Thorpe | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1997 | a10560 |
| 4 | GJ Whittall | England v Zimbabwe | 2000 | a12839 |
| 3 | RAE Tindall | Gloucestershire v Surrey | 1964 | a29 |
| 3 | SJ Storey | Derbyshire v Surrey | 1967 | a95 |
| 3 | D Wilson | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1969 | a204 |
| 3 | RGD Willis | Sussex v Surrey | 1970 | a390 |
| 3 | CH Lloyd | Surrey v Lancashire | 1972 | a768 |
| 3 | W Snowden | Surrey v Cambridge University | 1974 | a1140 |
| 3 | PI Pocock | Yorkshire v Surrey | 1974 | a1180 |
| 3 | GP Howarth | Lancashire v Surrey | 1977 | a2039 |
| 3 | AI Kallicharran | Surrey v Warwickshire | 1983 | a3767 |
| 3 | MA Lynch | Somerset v Surrey | 1985 | a4479 |
| 3 | Kapil Dev | England v India | 1986 | a4857 |
| 3 | M Azharuddin | England v India | 1986 | a4857 |
| 3 | MA Lynch | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1986 | a5009 |
| 3 | DA Reeve | Surrey v Warwickshire | 1990 | a6635 |
| 3 | CK Bullen | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1990 | a6689 |
| 3 | JP Stephenson | Surrey v Essex | 1991 | a6985 |
| 3 | AJ Moles | Surrey v Warwickshire | 1991 | a7026 |
| 3 | PA Booth | Surrey v Warwickshire | 1991 | a7026 |
| 3 | MA Crawley | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 1991 | a7105 |
| 3 | AD Brown | Lancashire v Surrey | 1993 | a8070 |
| 3 | AW Smith | New Zealanders v Surrey | 1994 | a8612 |
| 3 | GA Hick | Surrey v Worcestershire | 1994 | a8764 |
| 3 | MA Butcher | Warwickshire v Surrey | 1996 | a10031 |
| 3 | GP Thorpe | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | 1997 | a10608 |
| 3 | MJ Chilton | Surrey v British Universities | 1998 | a11151 |
| 3 | JD Ratcliffe | Lancashire v Surrey | 1998 | a11216 |
| 3 | GP Thorpe | Hampshire v Surrey | 2000 | a12755 |
| 3 | ESH Giddins | Gloucestershire v Surrey | 2002 | a14580 |
| 3 | MP Vaughan | India v England | 2004 | a16117 |
| 3 | BC Lara | England v West Indies | 2004 | a16174 |
| 3 | AD Brown | Somerset v Surrey | 2005 | a16815 |
| 3 | MCJ Ball | Surrey v Gloucestershire | 2006 | a17608 |
| 3 | SJ Walters | Northamptonshire v Surrey | 2008 | a19112 |
| 3 | JC Hildreth | Surrey v Somerset | 2010 | a20683 |
| 3 | JJ Cobb | Surrey v Leicestershire | 2011 | a21361 |
| 3 | JM Anderson | Sri Lanka v England | 2011 | a21397 |
| 3 | DJ Bravo | Pakistan v West Indies | 2013 | a22670 |
| 3 | VS Solanki | Sussex v Surrey | 2014 | a23462 |
| 3 | LE Plunkett | Surrey v Yorkshire | 2015 | a24174 |
| 3 | AR Patel | England Lions v India A | 2018 | a26512 |
| 3 | F du Plessis | England v South Africa | 2019 | a27396 |
| 3 | JE Root | South Africa v England | 2019 | a27396 |
| 3 | JH Wharton | Surrey v Yorkshire | 2024 | a30980 |