| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1900 | f5338 |
| 5 | RL Pratt | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 1961 | f23919 |
| 5 | MR Hallam | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 1964 | f25340 |
| 4 | GW Hillyard | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 1895 | f4239 |
| 4 | R Abel | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1895 | f4262 |
| 4 | AN Hornby | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 1895 | f4357 |
| 4 | J Tunnicliffe | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1896 | f4468 |
| 4 | H Whitehead | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | 1900 | f5305 |
| 4 | JE Walsh | Hampshire v Leicestershire | 1948 | f18088 |
| 4 | TW Graveney | Leicestershire v Gloucestershire | 1960 | f23211 |
| 4 | MJK Smith | Leicestershire v Warwickshire | 1961 | f23702 |
| 4 | PJ Sharpe | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1961 | f23893 |
| 4 | MJ Stewart | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1965 | f25988 |
| 4 | PJ Robinson | Leicestershire v Somerset | 1967 | f26790 |
| 4 | GAR Lock | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 1967 | f26835 |
| 4 | R Illingworth | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 1970 | f28240 |
| 4 | BF Davison | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 1971 | f28785 |
| 4 | RT Virgin | Leicestershire v Northamptonshire | 1973 | f29750 |
| 4 | JF Steele | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 1983 | f34632 |
| 4 | N Hussain | Leicestershire v Essex | 1991 | f39518 |
| 4 | HH Dippenaar | Glamorgan v Leicestershire | 2008 | f50839 |
| 4 | TJ New | Worcestershire v Leicestershire | 2008 | f50859 |
| 4 | LA Dawson | Leicestershire v Hampshire | 2021 | f60375 |
| 4 | WL Madsen | Leicestershire v Derbyshire | 2023 | f61530 |