| 7 | LD Sutton | Yorkshire v Lancashire | 2008 | f50849 |
| 6 | D Hunter | Middlesex v Yorkshire | 1909 | f7827 |
| 6 | JG Binks | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1962 | f24296 |
| 6 | RW Tolchard | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 1973 | f29682 |
| 6 | DL Bairstow | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1980 | f33058 |
| 6 | RJ Blakey | Glamorgan v Yorkshire | 2003 | f47304 |
| 6 | JA Simpson | Yorkshire v Middlesex | 2013 | f54975 |
| 6 | JM Bairstow | Middlesex v Yorkshire | 2013 | f54975 |
| 6 | K Verreynne | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 2025 | f62986 |