| 5 | AH Bakewell | Essex v Northamptonshire | 1928 | f12393 |
| 5 | AH Dyson | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 1939 | f16488 |
| 5 | MJ Stewart | Northamptonshire v Surrey | 1954 | f20612 |
| 4 | D Davies | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 1923 | f10624 |
| 4 | CH Tyler | Glamorgan v Northamptonshire | 1923 | f10624 |
| 4 | JS Nicholson | Glamorgan v Northamptonshire | 1926 | f11677 |
| 4 | JE Timms | Hampshire v Northamptonshire | 1927 | f12063 |
| 4 | CJ Barnett | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 1929 | f12770 |
| 4 | AW Wellard | Northamptonshire v Somerset | 1936 | f15338 |
| 4 | MEF Dunkley | Sussex v Northamptonshire | 1937 | f15875 |
| 4 | H Halliday | Northamptonshire v Combined Services | 1946 | f17190 |
| 4 | CA Milton | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 1955 | f20961 |
| 4 | Majid Khan | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 1968 | f27369 |