| 6 | FH Vigar | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1950 | f18721 |
| 6 | SG Law | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1998 | f43734 |
| 5 | JGW Harrold | Somerset v Essex | 1924 | f10834 |
| 5 | FH Vigar | Surrey v Essex | 1948 | f17934 |
| 5 | NS Asgarali | Essex v West Indians | 1957 | f21700 |
| 5 | RE East | Gloucestershire v Essex | 1966 | f26239 |
| 5 | AR Lewis | Essex v Glamorgan | 1970 | f28241 |
| 5 | BR Hardie | Sussex v Essex | 1983 | f34676 |
| 5 | VP Terry | Essex v Hampshire | 1989 | f38153 |
| 5 | PJ Prichard | Hampshire v Essex | 1989 | f38153 |
| 5 | N Hussain | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1994 | f41153 |
| 5 | D Byas | Essex v Yorkshire | 1997 | f43094 |