| 5 | GB Street | Worcestershire v Sussex | 1923 | f10627 |
| 5 | WL Cornford | Surrey v Sussex | 1929 | f12869 |
| 5 | JT Murray | West Indians v LEG Ames' XI | 1957 | f21983 |
| 5 | BA Barnett | England XI v Commonwealth XI | 1960 | f23460 |
| 5 | ATW Grout | AER Gilligan's XI v Australians | 1961 | f23981 |
| 4 | AFA Lilley | South v North | 1895 | f4368 |
| 4 | AFA Lilley | Surrey and Sussex v The Rest | 1900 | f5490 |
| 4 | GB Street | Gloucestershire v Sussex | 1914 | f9186 |
| 4 | JC Hubble | Sussex v Kent | 1924 | f11029 |
| 4 | TA Ward | South v South Africans | 1924 | f11078 |
| 4 | WL Cornford | Northamptonshire v Sussex | 1932 | f14011 |
| 4 | WL Cornford | Kent v Sussex | 1933 | f14393 |
| 4 | TG Evans | Sussex v Kent | 1951 | f19278 |
| 4 | HW Stephenson | England XI v Commonwealth XI | 1951 | f19381 |
| 4 | PG Joshi | AER Gilligan's XI v Indians | 1959 | f22950 |
| 4 | JM Parks | Kent v Sussex | 1960 | f23339 |
| 4 | JM Parks | Kent v Sussex | 1963 | f24887 |
| 4 | RW Taylor | Sussex v Derbyshire | 1963 | f24895 |
| 4 | IJ Gould | Gloucestershire v Sussex | 1982 | f34071 |
| 4 | APE Knott | Sussex v Kent | 1984 | f35269 |