| 6 | KS Duleepsinhji | Kent v Sussex | 1929 | f12873 |
| 6 | REC Pratt | Sussex v Surrey | 1956 | f21447 |
| 6 | ASM Oakman | Lancashire v Sussex | 1961 | f23840 |
| 5 | WW Read | North v South | 1888 | f3336 |
| 5 | JG Langridge | Kent v Sussex | 1946 | f17290 |
| 5 | GE Tribe | England XI v Commonwealth XI | 1954 | f20667 |
| 5 | JG Langridge | Warwickshire v Sussex | 1955 | f21002 |