| 5 | ASM Oakman | Lancashire v Sussex | 1961 | f23840 |
| 4 | W Newham | Players v Gentlemen | 1889 | f3436 |
| 4 | KO Goldie | Players of the South v Gentlemen of the South | 1905 | f6784 |
| 4 | RNR Blaker | Players of the South v Gentlemen of the South | 1907 | f7310 |
| 4 | GE Tribe | England XI v Commonwealth XI | 1954 | f20667 |
| 4 | SE Leary | Sussex v Kent | 1957 | f21898 |
| 4 | CA Milton | Commonwealth XI v England XI | 1957 | f21983 |
| 4 | MW Gatting | Sussex v Middlesex | 1989 | f38260 |