| 4 | BJ Meyer | Surrey v Gloucestershire | 1970 | a323 |
| 4 | GID Lavelle | Surrey v Lancashire | 2023 | a30153 |
| 3 | DA Pullan | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 1973 | a1052 |
| 3 | CJ Richards | Northamptonshire v Surrey | 1987 | a5317 |
| 3 | AJ Stewart | Gloucestershire v Surrey | 1993 | a8142 |
| 3 | AJ Stewart | Hampshire v Surrey | 1997 | a10626 |
| 3 | SJ Rhodes | Surrey v Worcestershire | 2003 | a15221 |
| 3 | GO Jones | Surrey v Kent | 2006 | a17524 |
| 3 | CMW Read | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 2012 | a22044 |
| 3 | GC Wilson | Derbyshire v Surrey | 2015 | a24192 |