| 6 | EM Grace | Surrey v Gloucestershire | 1877 | f2084 |
| 6 | EM Grace | Lancashire v Gloucestershire | 1878 | f2176 |
| 5 | WG Grace | Lancashire v Gloucestershire | 1878 | f2176 |
| 5 | JT Rawlin | Gloucestershire v Middlesex | 1899 | f5212 |
| 5 | AE Dipper | Glamorgan v Gloucestershire | 1929 | f12859 |