| 4 | SD Hope | Pakistan v West Indies | 2016/17 | a25435 |
| 3 | KC Sangakkara | South Africa v Sri Lanka | 2006/07 | a18151 |
| 3 | CAK Walton | Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2007/08 | a18416 |
| 3 | CAK Walton | Guyana v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2008/09 | a19220 |
| 3 | AL Dodson | Barbados v United States of America | 2008/09 | a19225 |
| 3 | PA Browne | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 2008/09 | a19262 |
| 3 | D Ramdin | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 2009/10 | a20117 |
| 3 | D Ramdin | Guyana v Trinidad and Tobago | 2009/10 | a20151 |
| 3 | DO Christian | Windward Islands v Guyana | 2011/12 | a21548 |
| 3 | Umar Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2013 | a22722 |
| 3 | Mushfiqur Rahim | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2018 | a26541 |