| 5 | DJG Sammy | Australia v West Indies | 2011/12 | f54012 |
| 5 | J Charles | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 2016/17 | f57590 |
| 4 | SJ Hinds | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 1975/76 | f30927 |
| 4 | WN Slack | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 1981/82 | f33997 |
| 4 | M Durand | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 1990/91 | f39188 |
| 4 | NC McGarrell | Windward Islands v Guyana | 1995/96 | f42291 |
| 4 | KK Sylvester | Guyana v Windward Islands | 1995/96 | f42291 |
| 4 | DA Joseph | Guyana v Windward Islands | 1995/96 | f42291 |
| 4 | D Ramnarine | Windward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 1996/97 | f42979 |
| 4 | TO Powell | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1997/98 | f43503 |
| 4 | EJM Cowan | West Indies v Australia | 2011/12 | f54012 |
| 4 | LR Johnson | Windward Islands v Guyana | 2014/15 | f56317 |
| 4 | MJ Clarke | West Indies v Australia | 2015 | f56420 |