| 6 | ED Solkar | West Indies v India | 1970/71 | f28602 |
| 6 | BC Lara | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 1993/94 | f40919 |
| 6 | VS Solanki | Trinidad and Tobago v England A | 2000/01 | f45533 |
| 5 | GR Bardswell | Trinidad v Lord Hawke's XI | 1896/97 | f4609 |
| 5 | NA Shurland | Trinidad v AB St Hill's XI | 1900/01 | f5502 |
| 5 | FH Hollins | Trinidad v RA Bennett's XI | 1901/02 | f5759 |
| 5 | LS Constantine | Marylebone Cricket Club v Trinidad | 1910/11 | f8169 |
| 5 | JS Dare | Trinidad v British Guiana | 1928/29 | f12593 |
| 5 | LN Constantine | Marylebone Cricket Club v Trinidad | 1929/30 | f12980 |
| 5 | CD Furlonge | Australians v Trinidad | 1954/55 | f20791 |
| 5 | GS Sobers | England v West Indies | 1959/60 | f23131 |
| 5 | BA Davis | Australians v Trinidad and Tobago | 1964/65 | f25692 |
| 5 | BA Davis | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 1969/70 | f28155 |
| 5 | RC Fredericks | Australia v West Indies | 1972/73 | f29574 |
| 5 | CB Lambert | Trinidad and Tobago v Guyana | 1986/87 | f36943 |
| 5 | AJ Lamb | West Indies v England | 1989/90 | f38667 |
| 5 | TO Powell | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 1993/94 | f40919 |
| 5 | BC Lara | England v West Indies | 1993/94 | f41043 |
| 5 | BC Lara | Leeward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 1996/97 | f43087 |
| 5 | ML Hayden | West Indies v Australia | 2002/03 | f47244 |
| 5 | A Jordan | Trinidad and Tobago v Barbados | 2022/23 | f61508 |