| 5 | D Williams | Indians v West Indies Board XI | 1988/89 | f38031 |
| 5 | JR Murray | Guyana v Windward Islands | 2001/02 | f46388 |
| 4 | U Pope | South Africa A v Windward Islands | 2000 | f45264 |
| 4 | N Pothas | West Indies A v South Africa A | 2000 | f45270 |
| 4 | KA Mason | Windward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 2000/01 | f45574 |
| 4 | JR Murray | Trinidad and Tobago v Windward Islands | 2004/05 | f48456 |
| 4 | CO Browne | Windward Islands v Barbados | 2004/05 | f48478 |
| 4 | LOD James | Combined Campuses and Colleges v Windward Islands | 2008/09 | f51517 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Pakistan A v West Indies A | 2010/11 | f52763 |
| 4 | Sarfraz Ahmed | West Indies A v Pakistan A | 2010/11 | f52763 |
| 4 | CAK Walton | Sri Lanka A v West Indies A | 2013 | f54882 |
| 4 | TT Walcott | Windward Islands v Barbados | 2018/19 | f59352 |
| 4 | EWJA Stewart | Barbados v Windward Islands | 2019/20 | f59861 |
| 4 | JM Da Silva | Windward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 2024/25 | f62777 |