| 5 | GRA Langley | West Indies v Australia | 1954/55 | t408 |
| 5 | PJL Dujon | India v West Indies | 1982/83 | t949 |
| 5 | WB Phillips | West Indies v Australia | 1983/84 | t988 |
| 5 | MV Boucher | West Indies v South Africa | 2000/01 | t1544 |
| 5 | Kamran Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2004/05 | t1754 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | West Indies v New Zealand | 2014 | t2123 |
| 5 | BJ Haddin | West Indies v Australia | 2015 | t2166 |
| 4 | CL Walcott | England v West Indies | 1947/48 | t298 |
| 4 | FCM Alexander | Pakistan v West Indies | 1957/58 | t450 |
| 4 | RW Marsh | West Indies v Australia | 1972/73 | t714 |
| 4 | Wasim Bari | West Indies v Pakistan | 1976/77 | t803 |
| 4 | Majid Khan | West Indies v Pakistan | 1976/77 | t803 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | Australia v West Indies | 1983/84 | t988 |
| 4 | A Flower | West Indies v Zimbabwe | 1999/00 | t1492 |
| 4 | Kamran Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2004/05 | t1754 |
| 4 | BJ Haddin | West Indies v Australia | 2008 | t1875 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Australia v West Indies | 2008 | t1875 |
| 4 | RR Pant | West Indies v India | 2019 | t2359 |
| 4 | JM Da Silva | Pakistan v West Indies | 2021 | t2430 |
| 4 | JM Da Silva | Pakistan v West Indies | 2021 | t2430 |