| 14-62 | ER Wilson | RA Bennett's XI v West Indies | 1901/02 | f5767 |
| 14-176 | Sarfraz Nawaz | Pakistanis v Guyana | 1976/77 | f31510 |
| 13-39 | HR Bromley-Davenport | RS Lucas' XI v Demerara | 1894/95 | f4186 |
| 13-135 | CR Browne | British Guiana v Barbados | 1925/26 | f11424 |
| 13-154 | OAC Banks | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 2009/10 | f52280 |
| 12-83 | OH Layne | WC Shepherd's XI v British Guiana | 1906/07 | f7043 |
| 12-87 | GJ Thompson | Lord Brackley's XI v British Guiana | 1904/05 | f6535 |
| 12-125 | CRW Chandler | Jamaica v British Guiana | 1896/97 | f4588 |
| 12-156 | S Ganouri | Berbice v Demerara | 1983/84 | f34830 |