| 6 | AP Binns | British Guiana v Jamaica | 1952/53 | f19817 |
| 5 | GRA Langley | West Indies v Australia | 1954/55 | f20801 |
| 5 | G Murray | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Guyana | 1969/70 | f28147 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Pakistan v West Indies | 1976/77 | f31513 |
| 5 | JR Murray | Guyana v Windward Islands | 1990/91 | f39211 |