| 4 | MR Marsh | West Indies v Australia | 2016 | a24804 |
| 3 | PJL Dujon | Barbados v Jamaica | 1975/76 | a1594 |
| 3 | CL King | Trinidad and Tobago v Barbados | 1975/76 | a1596 |
| 3 | AL Logie | New Zealand v West Indies | 1984/85 | a4369 |
| 3 | IVA Richards | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | a5965 |
| 3 | P Johnson | Barbados v England A | 1991/92 | a7449 |
| 3 | SL Campbell | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 1993/94 | a8461 |
| 3 | GP Thorpe | West Indies v England | 1993/94 | a8551 |
| 3 | MA Taylor | West Indies v Australia | 1994/95 | a9130 |
| 3 | RC Haynes | Barbados v Jamaica | 1995/96 | a9457 |
| 3 | S Chanderpaul | Barbados v Guyana | 1995/96 | a9485 |
| 3 | AJ Hollioake | West Indies v England | 1997/98 | a11082 |
| 3 | JC Adams | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | a11875 |
| 3 | DJG Sammy | England v West Indies | 2008/09 | a19678 |
| 3 | Marshall Ayub | Sagicor High Performance Centre v Bangladesh A | 2014 | a23394 |
| 3 | J Blackwood | Bangladesh A v Sagicor High Performance Centre | 2014 | a23394 |
| 3 | RO Hinds | Jamaica v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2016/17 | a25143 |
| 3 | SA Jacobs | Jamaica v Guyana | 2016/17 | a25148 |
| 3 | AR Nurse | Trinidad and Tobago v Barbados | 2017/18 | a25962 |
| 3 | KA Edwards | Hampshire v Windward Islands | 2017/18 | a26038 |
| 3 | RA Lewis | Jamaica v Guyana | 2018/19 | a26870 |
| 3 | KJ Cottoy | Guyana v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2018/19 | a26884 |
| 3 | JA Drakes | Guyana v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2018/19 | a26884 |
| 3 | PR Stirling | West Indies v Ireland | 2019/20 | a27927 |