| 6 | D Gamsy | Orange Free State v Natal | 1960/61 | f23634 |
| 6 | TM Roberts | Natal B v Western Province B | 1986/87 | f36599 |
| 5 | MS Smith | Western Province v Natal | 1958/59 | f22609 |
| 5 | GP Pfuhl | Natal v South African Universities | 1969/70 | f28022 |
| 5 | LH Fick | Natal B v Boland | 1982/83 | f34465 |
| 5 | CF Spilhaus | Natal B v Western Province B | 1991/92 | f39784 |
| 5 | GW Bashford | Western Province B v Natal B | 1991/92 | f39784 |