| 4 | PWA Mulder | Paarl Royals v Durban's Super Giants | 2023/24 | tt13143 |
| 3 | PJN Jeftha | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v Boland | 2011/12 | tt2562 |
| 3 | JP Duminy | Lions v Cape Cobras | 2013/14 | tt4039 |
| 3 | UKJ Birkenstock | Eastern Province v Boland | 2013/14 | tt4135 |
| 3 | R Moonsamy | Boland v Northerns | 2015/16 | tt5290 |
| 3 | PE Kruger | North West v Northern Cape | 2018/19 | tt7209 |
| 3 | KK Leokaoke | Boland v North West | 2018/19 | tt7212 |