| 4 | CR Matthews | Northern Transvaal v Western Province | 1988/89 | a5825 |
| 4 | F du Plessis | Eagles v Titans | 2009/10 | a20134 |
| 4 | HM Amla | Pakistan v South Africa | 2013/14 | a23064 |
| 4 | AK Markram | Cape Cobras v Titans | 2018/19 | a27197 |
| 3 | WF Morris | Impalas v Northern Transvaal | 1987/88 | a5555 |
| 3 | M Yachad | Orange Free State v Northern Transvaal | 1989/90 | a6335 |
| 3 | CJ van Heerden | Northern Transvaal v Orange Free State | 1991/92 | a7270 |
| 3 | TG Shaw | Northern Transvaal v Eastern Province | 1992/93 | a7781 |
| 3 | KC Wessels | Pakistan v South Africa | 1992/93 | a7958 |
| 3 | NC Johnson | Northerns v Natal | 1997/98 | a10766 |
| 3 | JH Kallis | West Indies v South Africa | 1998/99 | a11725 |
| 3 | GFJ Liebenberg | Northerns v Free State | 1999/00 | a12303 |
| 3 | M van Jaarsveld | Zimbabweans v Northerns | 1999/00 | a12389 |
| 3 | M van Jaarsveld | Eastern Province v Northerns | 2003/04 | a15451 |
| 3 | JP Duminy | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2009/10 | a19989 |
| 3 | JP Duminy | New Zealand v South Africa | 2009/10 | a20000 |
| 3 | SA Engelbrecht | Titans v Cape Cobras | 2009/10 | a20122 |
| 3 | JA Morkel | Warriors v Titans | 2009/10 | a20247 |
| 3 | F Behardien | Lions v Titans | 2010/11 | a20918 |
| 3 | RR Rossouw | Titans v Knights | 2010/11 | a20941 |
| 3 | AJ Pienaar | Titans v Knights | 2012/13 | a22186 |
| 3 | HE van der Dussen | Titans v Lions | 2015/16 | a24650 |
| 3 | AK Markram | Eastern Province v Northerns | 2016/17 | a24952 |
| 3 | AB de Villiers | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2016/17 | a25156 |
| 3 | LN Mosena | Northerns v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | 2017/18 | a25811 |
| 3 | DS Rosier | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v Northerns | 2018/19 | a26911 |
| 3 | JL du Plooy | Easterns v Northerns | 2018/19 | a27237 |
| 3 | JG Hermann | Northerns v Eastern Province | 2022/23 | a29694 |