| 6 | MS Dhoni | New Zealand v India | 2008/09 | t1918 |
| 6 | Adnan Akmal | New Zealand v Pakistan | 2010/11 | t1991 |
| 5 | RI Harford | India v New Zealand | 1967/68 | t632 |
| 5 | WK Lees | Sri Lanka v New Zealand | 1982/83 | t951 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | India v New Zealand | 2013/14 | t2120 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Sri Lanka v New Zealand | 2014/15 | t2155 |
| 5 | Imrul Kayes | New Zealand v Bangladesh | 2016/17 | t2246 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Sri Lanka v New Zealand | 2018/19 | t2335 |