| 6 | PR Downton | Otago v England XI | 1977/78 | f31966 |
| 5 | RW Rowntree | Otago v Auckland | 1928/29 | f12586 |
| 5 | ORD Whitford | Otago v Canterbury | 1947/48 | f17818 |
| 5 | AS Mills | Fiji v Otago | 1947/48 | f17848 |
| 5 | GH Mills | Northern Districts v Otago | 1957/58 | f22065 |
| 5 | TG McMahon | Otago v Wellington | 1960/61 | f23628 |
| 5 | T Flaws | Auckland v Otago | 1961/62 | f24107 |
| 5 | AC Parore | Otago v Auckland | 1988/89 | f37978 |
| 5 | SA Robinson | Canterbury v Otago | 1992/93 | f40392 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Otago v Wellington | 1995/96 | f42225 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Otago v Wellington | 1995/96 | f42225 |