| 4 | RE Redmond | Otago v Auckland | 1972/73 | a853 |
| 4 | GP Howarth | Australians v New Zealand Invitation XI | 1976/77 | a1843 |
| 4 | JR Wiltshire | Northern Districts v Auckland | 1978/79 | a2308 |
| 4 | MJ Guptill | Pakistan v New Zealand | 2015/16 | a24628 |
| 3 | Sarfraz Nawaz | Auckland v Pakistan | 1978/79 | a2317 |
| 3 | Mudassar Nazar | Auckland v Pakistan | 1978/79 | a2317 |
| 3 | MD Crowe | Australia v New Zealand | 1981/82 | a3205 |
| 3 | GRJ Matthews | New Zealand v Australia | 1985/86 | a4778 |
| 3 | AL Logie | New Zealand v West Indies | 1986/87 | a5164 |
| 3 | CM Brown | Northern Districts v Auckland | 1996/97 | a10304 |
| 3 | DJ Nash | Australia v New Zealand | 1997/98 | a11002 |
| 3 | JN Rhodes | New Zealand v South Africa | 1998/99 | a11774 |
| 3 | JH Kallis | New Zealand v South Africa | 1998/99 | a11774 |
| 3 | SP Fleming | Australia v New Zealand | 1999/00 | a12495 |
| 3 | MEK Hussey | New Zealand v Australia | 2004/05 | a16487 |
| 3 | MEK Hussey | New Zealand v Australia | 2006/07 | a18002 |
| 3 | HM Amla | New Zealand v South Africa | 2011/12 | a21859 |
| 3 | DM Bravo | New Zealand v West Indies | 2013/14 | a23155 |