| 5 | MD Bailey | Otago v Northern Districts | 1996/97 | f42930 |
| 5 | CZ Harris | Otago v Canterbury | 2003/04 | f47815 |
| 5 | DJ Mitchell | Otago v Canterbury | 2020/21 | f60252 |
| 4 | WL Blair | Wellington v Otago | 1980/81 | f33392 |
| 4 | GP Howarth | Otago v Northern Districts | 1981/82 | f33901 |
| 4 | JF Reid | Otago v Auckland | 1983/84 | f35002 |
| 4 | RN Hoskin | Northern Districts v Otago | 1991/92 | f39736 |
| 4 | SP Fleming | Otago v New Zealand Academy | 1993/94 | f41012 |
| 4 | JM Allan | Auckland v Otago | 1996/97 | f43018 |