| 6 | DA Murray | for West Indians | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 1979/80 | a2597 |
| 6 | GJ Hopkins | for Auckland | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2012/13 | a22520 |
| 5 | BD Milburn | for Otago | Centennial Park, Oamaru | 1982/83 | a3535 |
| 5 | C Cachopa | for Auckland | Saxton Oval, Nelson | 2013/14 | a23312 |
| 5 | BJ Horne | for Auckland | Bert Sutcliffe Oval, Lincoln | 2018/19 | a26919 |
| 4 | RG Hart | for Northern Districts | Trust Bank Park, Hamilton | 1993/94 | a8425 |
| 4 | JM Mills | for Auckland | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 1995/96 | a9585 |
| 4 | AC Parore | for Auckland | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 1997/98 | a10904 |
| 4 | MD Bell | for Wellington | Waikanae Park, Waikanae | 1999/00 | a12340 |
| 4 | GJ Hopkins | for Canterbury | Jade Stadium, Christchurch | 2000/01 | a13289 |
| 4 | CJ Nevin | for Wellington | Waikanae Park, Waikanae | 2001/02 | a14014 |
| 4 | RG Hart | for Northern Districts | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 2003/04 | a15613 |
| 4 | TA Blundell | for Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2016/17 | a25172 |
| 4 | TWM Latham | for Canterbury | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 2018/19 | a26877 |
| 4 | BJ Horne | for Auckland | John Davies Oval, Queenstown | 2021/22 | a28869 |
| 4 | TA Blundell | for Wellington | Fitzherbert Park, Palmerston North | 2022/23 | a29669 |
| 4 | BJ Horne | for Auckland | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 2022/23 | a29747 |