Teams Joe O'Connell played for

Hawke CupSouthland (1954/55)
 Central Otago (1963/64)
MiscellaneousSouthland (1954/55-1955/56)
 Otago Country Associations and Southland (1954/55)
 Central Otago (1957/58-1967/68)
 Central Otago XI (1966/67)
 Central Otago Wanderers (1981)